Tag: policy

  • 15. National Policy Recommendations

    • 1. Establish a higher-education identity working group, coordinated with (but distinct from) any K–12 School Contact working group. The Department of Technology initiative advocates for such working groups to exist at every level of government, but convening one does not require that department to exist first.

    • 2. Develop an open identity specification supporting concurrent institutional affiliation.

    • 3. Conduct an independent privacy assessment addressing adult-student FERPA rights.

    • 4. Conduct an independent cybersecurity assessment of the proposed domain and subdomain architecture.

    • 5. Define an institution-controlled subdomain governance model before any root-domain launch.

    • 6. Launch pilots across research universities, teaching colleges, and community colleges.

    • 7. Do not pursue mandatory or exclusive adoption until pilot evidence supports it.

  • 16. A National Imperative

    The preceding sections have been deliberately cautious. This paper has repeatedly said that College Contact’s claimed benefits are hypotheses requiring pilot evidence, that its architecture creates real risks alongside its benefits, and that legitimate technical, legal, and privacy criticism of this proposal exists and should be expected to persist through any research, review, or pilot process. That caution is intentional and should not be abandoned as this initiative moves forward.

    At the same time, the authors believe one point should not be in serious dispute: the United States is engaged in intense international competition over machine intelligence capability, and the outcome of that competition will shape economic strength, scientific leadership, and national security for decades. Other nations are investing heavily in MI research, talent, infrastructure, and adoption at national scale. Academia, industry, and government each hold a piece of the American response, but no single sector can carry it alone.

    College Contact is a modest proposal within that much larger context — an identity and communication layer for one sector, higher education. It will not, by itself, determine the outcome of that broader competition. But the authors believe the individual pieces of national MI capability — research infrastructure, talent pipelines, trusted data and identity systems, and the ability of institutions to adopt MI tools safely and quickly — accumulate. A nation that cannot verify who its researchers are, cannot coordinate its institutions, and cannot safely deploy MI tools at scale is a nation that moves more slowly than one that can.

    The authors believe this is a rare point where the case for action does not depend on resolving every political disagreement about MI policy, regulation, or risk first. Reasonable people will continue to disagree — and should continue to disagree — about how MI should be governed, what limits should apply, and how fast adoption should proceed. Those debates are legitimate and this paper does not attempt to resolve them. What the authors believe should command broad agreement, across institutions and across political lines, is that the United States benefits from exploring every responsible pathway toward MI capability and leadership, and that infrastructure proposals like College Contact are one small, specific contribution to that broader effort — offered for evaluation on their own merits, not as a substitute for the larger national effort they are meant to support.

  • FERPA and Adult Students: What the Rules Actually Say

    Unlike K–12, where parents typically hold FERPA rights on a student’s behalf, college students eighteen or older generally hold their own rights directly — including the right to control disclosure of their own education records, with some specific exceptions for things like directory information and certain parental notifications.

    This distinction is one of the reasons College Contact can’t simply reuse the School Contact Initiative’s K–12 model wholesale. Our white paper’s Privacy and Data Governance section works through how an identity and verification layer should handle adult student rights specifically, and what “authenticate more, expose less” means in practice.

    We’ll keep flagging relevant FERPA guidance updates here as they come out.

  • State Legislatures Are Starting to Regulate AI in the Classroom

    Several state legislatures have introduced or advanced bills this year addressing AI use in higher education, ranging from disclosure requirements to restrictions on how student interaction data with AI tools can be used or sold. The details vary widely by state, and enforcement mechanisms are still being worked out in most cases.

    This legislative activity is directly relevant to our white paper’s National Policy Recommendations section, which argues against premature mandatory adoption of any single framework, ours included, until pilot evidence exists. We’ll track meaningful state and federal developments here as they happen.